The Panel, Hamish Douglass (sitting President), Rod Halstead and Nora Scheinkestel, declined to conduct proceedings on an application by McDermott Industries Limited for a review of the initial Panel's decision in Mission NewEnergy Limited [2012] ATP 19. The review Panel considered that the exclusivity provision was no longer linked to a control transaction, and in any event was not unacceptable given the commercial reality that Mission faced. Accordingly, the review Panel considered there was no reasonable prospect of it coming to a different conclusion to the initial Panel.